The Bombay High Court, while setting aside the sanction granted by the ICICI Bank's Board of Directors to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to prosecute its former CEO Chanda Kochhar under the Prevention of Corruption Act, held that the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the 'competent authority' to grant such a sanction.

Single-judge Justice Milind Jadhav while referring to the provisions of the Banking Regulation (BR) Act of 1949, noted that a CEO or the Managing Director of a bank can be removed only after prior approval from the RBI.

"Section 36-AA(1) of the BR Act, categorically states that when the Reserve Bank is satisfied that in the public interest or for preventing the affairs of a banking company being conducted in a manner detrimental to the interest of the depositors or for securing proper management of any banking company it is necessary to do so, the Reserve Bank may, for reasons to be recorded in writing, by order, remove from office, with effect from such date as may be specified in the order, any Chairman, Director, Chief Executive Officer by whatever name called, or other officer or employee of the banking company. Thus the power of removal vests with RBI and RBI only. Thus, there is no sanction order passed by the Competent Authority which is the RBI. No reasons are given by the RBI for removal of the Petitioner for that matter for issuing sanction order. Reasons for removal / sanction order are not recorded in writing by the RBI," Justice Jadhav held.

In his 57-page order, the judge made it clear that though trial in the instant case, has not commenced, the very fact that cognisance is taken on the basis of the impugned defective sanction itself nullifies all past and future procedure followed by the Special Court.

"Nullity of sanction goes to the root of prosecution's case in proceedings under the PC Act as it is a jurisdictional foundational fact and it would stand on the same pedestal as an absent sanction," the judge remarked.

The judge pointed out that the RBI has not passed any order of removal against Kochhar and most importantly if at all any such order is required to be passed by the RBI, her valuable statutory right to have been given a reasonable opportunity of making a representation to the RBI against the proposed order has been lost altogether

"In the present case, it is seen that charges under PC Act were levied against Petitioner for allegedly receiving improper consideration while exercising her powers as Managing Director of ICICI Bank and therefore the CBI sought grant of sanction to prosecute Petitioner from Board of Directors of ICICI Bank, however power to remove Managing Director, any Director or officer from the banking company vested solely with Reserve Bank of India and with no other body, entity or authority including the Board of Directors of the banking company. The Board of Directors of ICICI Bank cannot be the authority competent to remove the Petitioner, and therefore accord sanction for prosecution and hence the document of sanction for prosecution issued by the Board dated May 15, 2023 is not a valid sanction under Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act," the judge held.

Since sanction in the present case is granted by an incompetent authority, such sanction ipso facto becomes illegal and a nullity as a result of which cognisance (of the chargesheet) taken by the Special Court of the offence under the PC Act is illegal and deserves to be set aside, the judge opined.

Further, the bench noted that the even while granting sanction, the Board of Directors failed to consider the material collected by the CBI against Kochhar and did not examine any evidence against her and just proceeded to grant the sanction.

"There is not an ounce of evidence to show that the sanctioning authority considered any material collected by the CBI, if any, in its investigation of Petitioner. There is not a whisper of any discussion on the evidence against Petitioner, if any, neither in the Minutes of Meeting of Board of Directors nor in the sanction granted therefrom, instead a mere conjecture and allegation is stated therein which cannot form a reasonable basis to prosecute the Petitioner even otherwise. The Special Court ought not to mechanically have taken cognisance of the chargesheet in Petitioner's case and instead ought to have carefully perused the impugned sanction to understand whether the authority that granted it was competent to do so in law in the present case," the judge observed.

With these observations, the judge quashed and set aside the sanction accorded by the Board of Directors.

Appearance:

Senior Advocate Abad Ponda along with Advocates Rohan Dakshini, Pooja Kothari, Nimit Bhimjiyani, Aditya Upadhyay and Parth Khubalkar instructed by Rashmikant and Partners appeared for the Petitioner.

Additional Solicitor General Anil Singh assisted by Special Public Prosecutor Kuldeep Patil along with Advocates Adarsh Vyas, Digvijay Kachare, Krishnakant Deshmukh, Sumitkumar Nimbalkar, Anay Joshi, Saili Dhuru, Saniki Joshi and Yukta Sawant represented the CBI.