“[A]fter Chandra announced on 12 August 2026 that he did not seek reappointment, all of us, including both of you, agreed at our meeting of 13 August 2026 to respect his wishes and to begin constituting a Selection Committee for a new Chairman,” Khambata wrote.

“Did Venu, as a Trust nominee Director, draw the attention of Tata Sons’ NRC to that resolution when it resolved on 3 September 2026 to ask Chandra to continue? Your ‘complete’ sequence of events leaves out these crucial facts.”

The disclosure raises new questions about the Tata Sons board’s 17 September decision to give Chandrasekaran a third five-year term, starting February next year, despite opposition from Tata Trusts chairman Noel Tata. Noel has called the reappointment invalid, while Tata Sons has defended it.

Tata Sons’ own account suggests Chandrasekaran had indeed decided to step aside. In a statement on 17 September, the company said its nomination and remuneration committee (NRC) had met to reconsider the matter.

War of letters

“On 3 September 2026, the Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC) of the Board of Tata Sons met to discuss the aforesaid letter and discuss the issue of re-appointment of Chandra as Executive Chairman,” Tata Sons said. “After due deliberation and in recognition of his contributions and the larger interests of the Tata Group, the NRC unanimously resolved to request him to reconsider his decision and to recommend him for re-appointment at the next Board meeting.”

Khambata’s letter responds to an 11 November letter from Srinivasan and Singh, which questioned whether the fight over Tata Sons was about protecting the Tata model or about keeping control of Tata Sons with the current leaders of the Trusts. That letter, Khambata noted, was “addressed to me and sent to the Trusts but, strangely, not to me.”

“It is apparent that because I called out 17 September, I am now subjected to a personal attack. My conscience is clear, and my cause is unaffected by any personal interest. I will not respond in kind.”

On their charge that he ignored a 17 October 2024 resolution, which morally required trustees to vote to reappoint one another, Khambata said Srinivasan, Singh and Noel Tata had voted against reappointing fellow trustee Mehli Mistry.

Why the Trusts are stuck

Khambata also rejected the suggestion that he plotted to “temporarily oust” Srinivasan so the Trusts could be reshaped. “What takes the cake is your suggestion,” he wrote. At the same 11 November 2025 meeting where he proposed Noel’s son Neville Tata as a trustee, Singh proposed former Titan chief executive officer, Bhaskar Bhat. “Was that also a strategic move by you to take advantage of Venu’s absence? Indeed not.”

Khambata’s second three-year stint at the Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT) and the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT) ended last week, after he chose not to seek another term. In his 2 November letter on leaving, he called 17 September “a day that will live in infamy”. Srinivasan’s vote was key to that day’s outcome.

Trustee appointments and reappointments need approval from all trustees, and internal disagreements have limited the Trusts’ ability to add or reappoint members. For this reason, former Citibank India head Pramit Jhaveri chose not to seek reappointment at SDTT earlier this year.

Because Srinivasan and Singh’s views differ from those of the other trustees, Khambata’s reappointment could have run into trouble. He decided not to seek another term despite Noel asking him to continue.

SDTT and SRTT own 27.98% and 23.56% of Tata Sons, respectively. Besides Noel, Srinivasan and Singh, SDTT’s trustees are Neville Tata and Bhaskar Bhat. SRTT’s four trustees are Noel, Srinivasan, Pune-based businessman and philanthropist Jehangir H.C. Jehangir, and Jimmy Tata.

Varun Sood

Varun Sood has been a business journalist writing on corporate affairs for the past 17 years. He currently oversees corporate coverage, including information technology (IT) services, aviation, auto, metals and mining, and conglomerates at Mint. He started as a reporter at Business Standard in 2005, after a short internship at the Economic and Political Weekly. Having worked across newsrooms in Delhi and Mumbai, including at DNA, the Financial Times, and the Economic Times, he is now based in Bengaluru. He is most proud of his work over the last decade at Mint, including writing about the rise and fall of some CEOs at Infosys, TCS, Cognizant, and Wipro. His first book, “Azim Premji: The Man Beyond the Billions”, was published by HarperCollins in October 2020. These days, he is spending more time reading annual reports and analysts' transcripts. Varun’s two pet peeves are access journalism and the dying art of interviews with business leaders. If you think there is something wrong inside your company or there are problems with corporate governance that you'd like to highlight, email him at varun.sood@livemint.com.

Satish John

Satish John serves as the Managing Editor at Mint, bringing over 30 years of experience in business journalism. He began his career in 1996 as a reporter at the Telegraph after a brief stint in the corporate sector. During his three decades of journalism, Satish has written on almost all sectors, including conglomerates, power, metals and mining, aviation and auto. Before joining Mint in 2022 (this is his second stint with the paper after earlier working from 2008 to 2011), Satish worked at The Economic Times and DNA. At Mint, Satish oversees the corporate, banking and markets coverage. One of his key roles is to manage news reporting teams and ensure their coordination across cities. The other important role he plays is in helping the paper get big news scoops and stories. His colleagues say he is a great raconteur and always has some interesting stories about promoters and companies. These days, Satish is exploring podcasts and AI tools to better tell stories and reach a wider audience. Inside the newsroom, reporters and editors continue to ideate with Satish to better their stories.