Indiana father on disability ordered to sell $270,000 home.

An Indiana man who receives disability payments and says he cannot afford to relocate has been ordered to sell his $270,000 marital home as part of his divorce settlement. However, an appeals court has overturned the order requiring him to contribute towards his daughter's college expenses, citing concerns over his ability to pay. The Indiana Court of Appeals, in a November 17 decision, upheld the trial court's division of marital property, including the sale of the house in Plainfield. But it reversed the direction that the father and his former wife each pay one-third of their daughter's college costs for four years, provided she maintained a cumulative grade point average of at least 2.5. The appeals court said the trial court had not adequately considered the father's financial circumstances or the statutory factors governing orders for post-secondary education expenses.

Why the father was asked to sell his $270,000 home

According to the court decision, the couple purchased the Plainfield property in 2018 for $172,500. The father continued living there after their separation, while the mother moved out in December 2022. The trial court valued the house at $270,000 and ordered its sale, with the father receiving the first $9,375 from the proceeds as credit for mortgage payments made during the divorce proceedings. The remaining net proceeds were to be divided equally. The father argued that selling the house would cause him hardship. He said he had been unable to work since 2019 and depended entirely on long-term disability payments linked to his previous employment with Amazon. Court records showed that he received about $997 twice a month, or nearly $23,920 annually. He also said he had only $600 in his checking account and could not afford to move or find another place to live. However, the appeals court found no basis to overturn the trial court's division of marital property, noting that the house represented a substantial part of the couple's marital estate.

Why the appeals court overturned the college expense order

The father also challenged the direction to contribute towards his daughter's college education, arguing that the court had failed to account for his limited income and financial obligations.

Join conversation

Share your thoughts in the comments

Be respectful · TOI community guidelines

The mother had submitted an estimate showing that attending Indiana University-Indianapolis would cost about $28,430 a year, with grants expected to cover $16,895. The father said he could not afford the additional expense. The appeals court noted that Indiana law requires courts to consider a child's ability to contribute through work, loans or financial aid, as well as each parent's ability to meet the costs. It also said an award should not be made if it would impose a substantial financial burden. Finding that the trial court had not made the required findings, the appeals court reversed the college expense order. It also directed the lower court to divide the costs of the daughter's optional activities according to the parents' incomes, with the father paying 43 per cent and the mother 57 per cent. The court further ruled that the mother should be entitled to claim the children as dependents for tax purposes. The case was sent back to the trial court for an amended divorce decree.

End of Article