Market Mastery
Webinar by Vishal Malkan
Find the weak links
in your portfolio by Vishal Malkan
A US federal judge has struck down the Trump administration's proposed restrictions on how long foreign students and journalists can remain in the country, providing relief to thousands of international students, including a large number of Indians pursuing higher education in the United States.
US District Judge F Dennis Saylor in Boston formally vacated the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) rule on Monday, November 16, under Section 706 of the Administrative Procedure Act. He declared the policy “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law.”
The decision follows an earlier order in September, when Saylor temporarily blocked the regulation just a day before it was due to take effect. At the time, he described the government's reasoning as based on “exceptionally weak” rationales.
The Trump administration has already taken the matter to the higher courts.
The ruling is particularly significant for Indian students, who form the largest group of international students in the US. It means they will not face the proposed four-year limit on their stay under the new rule and can continue to follow the existing system, subject to meeting their visa requirements.
What were Trump's proposed visa restrictions?
The DHS had proposed replacing the existing duration-of-status system for international students with fixed periods of admission.
Under the plan, foreign students entering the US on F-1 visas would have been allowed to remain in the country for a maximum of four years. Students whose courses or research required more time would have had to apply for an extension.
Under the existing arrangement, students can remain in the US for the duration of their academic programmes as long as they continue to meet the conditions of their visas.
The proposal also sought to restrict the stay of foreign journalists holding I visas to 240 days, or around eight months. They would have been required to seek extensions for similar periods to continue working in the country. Chinese journalists would have faced a shorter initial limit of 90 days, with the possibility of applying for further 90-day extensions.
The restrictions were not limited to students and journalists. They also covered researchers, professors and instructors entering the US under J visas.
The Trump administration argued that fixed admission periods and a formal extension process would help immigration authorities monitor foreign nationals more effectively and identify visa fraud and overstays.
Why did the US judge strike down the rule?
Judge Saylor found that the DHS had not adequately explained why the proposed restrictions were necessary or established that they would improve the government's ability to prevent immigration fraud and protect national security.
He also questioned whether the department had properly assessed the financial and academic consequences of the policy, considered less restrictive alternatives or adequately addressed objections raised during the public consultation process.
In his ruling, Saylor said the proposed restrictions could undermine the very purpose of allowing international students to pursue higher education in the US.
"Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity - providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States - that Congress sought to permit and encourage," the judge said.
He pointed out that the four-year limit could create serious problems for students enrolled in longer academic programmes, particularly doctoral courses and joint degrees.
The policy would "prohibit foreign students from engaging in extended periods of study, such as those required for PhD programs; prohibit them from obtaining joint degrees (and) prohibit them from changing their academic concentration," he said.
The court also questioned why the government needed to introduce a new system when existing mechanisms were already available to monitor international students.
These include the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS), which allows authorities to track student records and identify possible visa violations. The system is also used to investigate suspected cases of so-called 'pay-to-stay' fraud and potentially fraudulent overstays.
Saylor questioned how requiring students to seek discretionary extensions after four years would significantly improve the government's ability to detect such violations.
He also found that the DHS's interpretation of its powers could conflict with the purpose of the F-1 visa programme under the Immigration and Nationality Act, which allows eligible foreign nationals to enter the US temporarily to pursue a full course of study.
Why is the ruling a relief for Indian students?
India is the largest source of international students in the United States, with approximately 340,000 Indian students enrolled at American universities.
The proposed four-year cap could have affected thousands of them, particularly those pursuing PhD programmes, joint degrees and long-term research projects that often require more than four years to complete.
Under the existing duration-of-status system, Indian students can continue their academic programmes without having to seek an extension simply because they have crossed a fixed four-year admission period. They must, however, continue to comply with the conditions of their visas.
The ruling is also relevant for Indian students who move between academic specialisations or pursue additional qualifications in the US. The proposed regulation could have made such changes more difficult by requiring them to seek extensions under a discretionary system.
Why the ruling matters for US universities and technology companies
The implications extend beyond university campuses. Indian students are an important part of the US research, technology and science workforce.
A significant share of international graduates entering America's STEM workforce comes from India. Many Indian students take up jobs with US technology companies after graduation, contribute to research programmes, establish startups and pay taxes.
The proposed restrictions could have disrupted the pipeline of international talent available to universities, research institutions and companies, particularly in sectors that depend on advanced technical skills.
The impact of the wider immigration crackdown was already visible in student visa trends. F-1 visa approvals for Indian students reportedly fell by 62 per cent between May and August 2026, while the number of active Indian students in the US declined by more than 13 per cent over one year.
The latest court ruling removes the proposed four-year admission limit, but it does not reverse the decline in visa approvals or guarantee easier visa processing for Indian applicants.
For now, Indian students and other international scholars will continue under the existing duration-of-status framework, subject to the usual visa conditions, while the Trump administration pursues its legal challenge.




