The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) on November 19, 2026, released three reports presenting the findings of Cycle 1 full peer reviews of 18 jurisdictions concerning their implementation of the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard for improving the effectiveness and efficiency of the mutual agreement procedure (MAP).

The reports cover:

Austria, Germany, Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta, and the United States—read the 420-page report

Czechia, France, Italy, Japan, Latvia, and Malaysia—read the 424-page report

Denmark, Finland, Morocco, Norway, Romania, and Spain—read the 451-page report

Under BEPS Action 14, members of the OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework on BEPS committed to implementing a minimum standard to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of MAP, which enables jurisdictions to resolve disputes arising from the interpretation and application of income tax treaties.

Overall findings

The peer reviews generally demonstrate progress toward implementation of the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard, while identifying areas for further improvement. Recurring issues across the jurisdictions include completing the alignment of treaty networks with the minimum standard, ensuring adequate competent-authority resources, improving the timely resolution and implementation of MAP cases, and ensuring access to MAP in eligible cases.

The OECD found varying levels of implementation of the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard across the 18 jurisdictions:

Ireland, Japan, Latvia, Luxembourg, Malta, Morocco, and the United States meet almost all elements of the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard

Austria, Denmark, Finland, France, Malaysia, and Norway meet most elements

Germany meets the majority of the elements

Spain meets half of the elements

Czechia, Italy, and Romania meet fewer than half of the elements

The reports identify treaty-network alignment with the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard as an area for further work. Jurisdictions are addressing treaty-network deficiencies through bilateral negotiations and, when applicable, the MLI.

MAP inventories and timeliness

Average MAP completion times varied across the jurisdictions reviewed. Among the jurisdictions for which specific average completion times were reported, Ireland (approximately 13 months), Luxembourg (approximately 14 months), Latvia (17.07 months), Norway (17.53 months), Germany (23.89 months), and Finland (23.55 months) reported average completion times below 24 months.

Denmark reported an average slightly above 24 months. Austria (approximately 33 months), Malta (approximately 46 months), and the United States (approximately 37 months) remained above the target. Czechia, France, Italy, Japan, and Malaysia also exceeded the 24-month target, with average completion times ranging from approximately 27 to 33 months.

The reports identify resource constraints, aging inventories, delays in communication, and the complexity of certain cases as factors affecting timely resolution in a number of jurisdictions.

United States

The United States meets almost all elements of the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard and achieved a substantial reduction of its MAP inventory. Its average MAP resolution time remained approximately 37 months, significantly above the 24-month target.

The OECD also found that close to one-third of U.S. tax treaties are not fully aligned with the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard and identified issues regarding the timely implementation of MAP agreements.

Jurisdiction-specific findings

The peer reviews identify a number of additional jurisdiction-specific issues: