As India observes National Press Day on November 16, it will be worthwhile to revisit some recent judgments where the Courts have underscored the importance of press freedom and protected journalists from invasive State actions.
Although press freedom is not expressly guaranteed under the Constitution, the Supreme Court has consistently held that the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) includes freedom of the press(Sakal Papers v. Union of India (1962)). In Bennet Coleman v. Union of India (1972), the Supreme Court condemned prior restraints on press freedoms, and frowned upon regulatory measures which are specifically aimed at curbing the media. “The Press has the right of free propagation and free circulation without any previous restraint on publication. If a law were to single out the press for laying down prohibitive burdens on it that would restrict the circulation, penalise its freedom of choice as to personnel, prevent newspapers from being started and compel the press to Government aid, this would violate Art. 19(1) (a) and would fall outside the Protection afforded by Art. 19(2).”
The role of the press in a democracy was explained as “speaking truth to the power” and helping citizens to make free choices in a democracy in Madhyamam Broadcasting v. Union of India (2023).
"An independent press is vital for the robust functioning of a Democratic Republic. Its role in the democratic society is crucial, for it shines a light on the functioning of the State. The press has a duty to speak truth and present citizens with hard facts, enabling them to make choices that prepare democracy in the right direction. The restriction on the freedom of the press compels citizens to think along the same tangent. A homogenized view on issues that range from socioeconomic polity to political ideologies would pose grave dangers to democracy," it said.
Protection of journalistic sources important
In the 2021 Pegasus case (Manohar Lal Sharma v Union of India), the Supreme Court observed that surveillance will have a chilling effect on the freedom of press. The Court noted that the protection of journalistic sources is one of the basic conditions for the freedom of press.
The judgment observed :
"An important and necessary corollary of such a right is to ensure the protection of sources of information. Protection of journalistic sources is one of the basic conditions for the freedom of the press. Without such protection, sources may be deterred from assisting the press in informing the public on matters of public interest.”
Opining on the effect disproportionate State surveillance can have on the freedom of the press, the Court remarked,
"This is of particular concern when it relates to the freedom of the press, which is an important pillar of democracy. Such chilling effect on the freedom of speech is an assault on the vital public-watchdog role of the press, which may undermine the ability of the press to provide accurate and reliable information."
Bloomberg case : SC cautions against casual passing of pre-trial injunctions against media.
In Bloomberg Television Production Services India Pvt. Ltd. v. Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd(2024), the Court urged the trial courts to be cautious while granting pre-trial injunctions against the publication of media articles and journalistic pieces in defamation suits.
An interim injunction to take down an article not only impacts the author's right to publish but also the public's right to know, reminded the Court. The Court also urged the trial courts to take note of the trend of SLAPP (Strategic Litigation against Public Participation) whereby entities with vast economic resources use litigation to prevent public from knowing about their operations involving public interest.
"Significanty, in suits concerning defamation by media platforms and/or journalists, an additional consideration of balancing the fundamental right to free speech with the right to reputation and privacy must be borne in mind. The constitutional mandate of protecting journalistic expression cannot be understated, and courts must tread cautiously while granting pre-trial interim injunctions," the Court stated.
"The grant of a pre-trial injunction against the publication of an article may have severe ramifications on the right to freedom of speech of the author and the public's right to know," the Court stated.
"An injunction, particularly ex-parte, should not be granted without establishing that the content sought to be restricted is 'malicious' or 'palpably false'. Granting interim injunctions, before the trial commences, in a cavalier manner results in the stifling of public debate. In other words, courts should not grant ex-parte injunctions except in exceptional cases where the defence advanced by the respondent would undoubtedly fail at trial. In all other cases, injunctions against the publication of material should be granted only after a fullfledged trial is conducted or in exceptional cases, after the respondent is given a chance to make their submissions," the Court explained.
Media has the right to report oral proceedings in the Court
In Election Commission of India v MR Vijaya Bhaskar (2021), the Supreme Court upheld the right of the media to report oral exchanges in Court hearings, by linking it to the citizens' right to know. The Court rejected a plea by the Election Commission of India, which was filed in the context of the controversy created by the Madras High Court's oral comment that the ECI must be tried for murder for allowing election rallies during the Covid pandemic.
Rejecting the plea of ECI to stop media reporting of oral remarks as lacking in substance, the Court emphasized that the media coverage of court hearings was part of freedom of press, had a bearing on citizens' right to information and also on the accountability of the judiciary.
"Freedom of speech and expression extends to reporting proceedings in judicial institutions as well", the Court held.
"Courts are entrusted to perform crucial functions under the law. Their work has a direct impact, not only on the rights of citizens, but also the extent to which the citizens can exact accountability from the executive whose duty it is to enforce the law. Citizens are entitled to ensure that courts remain true to their remit to be a check on arbitrary exercises of power. The ability of citizens to do so bears a direct correlation to the seamless availability of information about what happens in a court during the course of proceedings. Therein lies the importance of freedom of the media to comment on and write about proceedings", the Court observed.
Contempt power cannot be used to regulate media freedom
In Wikimedia Foundation Inc. v. ANI Media Private Limited (2025), the Supreme Court set aside a order passed by the Delhi High Court in contempt proceedings for deletion of a wikipedia page. The Supreme Court emphasised that it is not the judiciary's role to instruct the media on what to take down. Reiterating that courts are open public institutions, the Bench held that even sub judice matters may be debated by the public and the press.
The judgement observed that both the judiciary and the media are foundational pillars of democracy and must complement each other for a liberal constitutional order to survive. The ruling strongly endorsed public discourse, media scrutiny and even critical commentary as essential democratic functions.
“Both the judiciary and the media are the foundational pillars of democracy which is a basic feature of our Constitution. For a liberal democracy to thrive, both must supplement each other."
Press can't be termed anti-establishment merely for criticising the Government
In Madhyamam Broadcasting (2023), while lifting the telecast ban on Malayalam news channel MediaOne, the Court observed that media cannot be termed as “anti-establishment” merely for criticising the Government.
"The use of such a terminology in itself represents an expectation that the press must support the establishment. The action of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting by denying your security clearance to a media channel on the basis of the views with the channel is constitutionally entitled to hold produces a chilling effect on free speech and in particularly on press freedom", it said.
UP Police notice to X for journalist's social media usage details quashed




