Shaina NC, others tear pages of Sonia Gandhi’s book: Video
In her memoir, Gandhi describes Savarkar as the founder of an ideology that views India as “primarily a nation where Hindus are supreme”. She contrasts his vision with Mahatma Gandhi’s, criticises the ideology for dismissing constitutional rights and describes Hindutva as a “deeply conservative ideology” that endorses a “patriarchal and hierarchical order”. She also refers to Savarkar’s mercy petitions to the British and alleges that RSS members acted as informers for the colonial authorities.
The protest, however, took an unexpected turn when Shaina purportedly tore a portion of a photograph showing Bal Thackeray hitting the effigy of former Union minister Mani Shankar Aiyar in 2004 over his remarks on Savarkar. Realising the mistake, she stopped midway after fellow spokesperson Sanjay Nirupam pointed it out.
“Balasaheb Thackeray is our deity. We are taking forward his thoughts,” Shaina said, maintaining that she had intended to tear Aiyar’s photograph. “I tore Manishankar’s photograph. I did not tear Balasaheb’s photograph,” she said.
Later, reacting to the backlash, Shaina NC said, “Show me where I have torn or disrespected Hindu hruday samrat Balasaheb Thackeray’s photograph. Deliberately twisting an incident to create a false narrative will not be tolerated. Anyone spreading defamatory claims against me will face legal action.”
Story continues below this ad
The incident triggered sharp reactions. Sena (UBT) leader Kishori Pednekar demanded Shaina’s resignation, while UBT corporators raised the issue in the BMC House, prompting an Opposition walkout. Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut also reacted on social media.
Maharashtra Congress president Harshwardhan Sapkal termed the episode an example of the Shinde Sena’s “mental bankruptcy”, while MLA Vijay Wadettiwar said, “Yesterday was Balasaheb’s death anniversary. Today, you are tearing his photograph. This is the height of shamelessness.”
Congress leader Nana Patole demanded a police case against those involved, while Sachin Sawant said, “You can tear a book, but how will you tear the truth? The wise argue; the ignorant tear books.”
Sena (UBT) leader Sushma Andhare accused the Shinde faction of betraying the ideology it claims to uphold. Congress workers also staged protests in Amravati.
Story continues below this ad
The Shinde Sena spokespersons had also demanded an apology from Uddhav over his acceptance of Gandhi’s memoir. “Savarkar is our love. Do not make allegations against him,” spokesperson Shital Mhatre said, asking Uddhav to apologise to Maharashtra for his alleged silence.




