Mauricio Pochettino’s appointment at Manchester United has been in the making for a decade, but the path to him replacing Michael Carrick as head coach in the coming days traces back around two weeks, to before their Premier League game away to Chelsea on October 31.
That is when the club were alerted to Pochettino having a $10million (£7.6m) buyout clause in his contract with the United States’ men’s national team. From that moment, attention among those in charge at the club focused on the 54-year-old Argentinian.
The Athletic has talked to multiple sources with knowledge of the situation, all speaking anonymously to protect relationships, to understand the process behind Pochettino’s recruitment. They revealed:
Aston Villa’s reaction to United testing waters on Unai Emery
The role played by Joel and Avram Glazer
Why Pochettino might adopt style of manager
Brighton owner Tony Bloom putting a £15m price on Fabian Hurzeler
Como’s Cesc Fabregas being discussed
Sir Jim Ratcliffe believing that hiring Antonio Conte could work
How talks on former France manager Didier Deschamps went
What happened with former Newcastle United coach Eddie Howe
This is the comprehensive account of how Pochettino finally got a job he has long coveted, and why United believe he will bring stability and success after yet another period of turbulence.
Once United understood the terms under which they could secure Pochettino, he emerged as the clear frontrunner among the candidates to succeed Carrick. He had twice failed to win the Old Trafford job across interviews by different regimes (more of which later), but in United’s current circumstances he ticked several important boxes, given his prior experience in both the Premier League and Champions League, his record for bringing through youth, his personality and his culture-building. Importantly, he was also keen on the role.
Executives had, by that point, sounded out Unai Emery, who is once again rebuilding Aston Villa while simultaneously having them compete both domestically and in Europe. Emery has been proposed to United at different stages in the past, and Sir Alex Ferguson is known to admire his qualities as a manager.
Calls took place, via intermediaries, enabling United to explore the cost of any move for Emery and his openness to joining them. But the 55-year-old Spaniard, whose agent is Jorge Mendes, has a level of control at Villa that is difficult for any club to match, and instead of heading to Manchester, talks progressed on a new contract with the Birmingham club, with his current terms running to 2029.
Villa took the unusual step of posting an update to their X account on November 4, which pictured Emery alongside the club’s co-owner and chairman Nassef Sawiris, to state how “positive discussions establishing a clear commitment beyond 2029” had taken place that day.
There is a sense among some close to United that the interest in him from Old Trafford enhanced and accelerated Emery’s forthcoming new contract at Villa.
Pochettino, however, was always receptive.
For years, he has spoken highly of United, having been at Barcelona’s Camp Nou in 1999 (he was a player for Espanyol, the Catalan city’s other top-flight club, at the time) to witness their comeback win against Bayern Munich in the Champions League final, and his admiration for Old Trafford icon Ferguson is evident.
He even expressed his designs on United publicly a few days before his USMNT beat Bosnia and Herzegovina to reach the last 16 of this year’s World Cup. During a media interview at the Ritz-Carlton in Laguna Niguel, near Los Angeles, Pochettino turned to his long-term assistant Jesus Perez and said, according to The Telegraph: “One day, your dream comes true. You go to Manchester United.”
It will cost United extra to obtain Perez, who is regarded as a pivotal figure for Pochettino, as well as the rest of his backroom team, which includes assistant coach Miguel D’Agostino, goalkeeping coach Antonio Jimenez, strength and conditioning coach Silvia Tuya Vinas and sports scientist Sebastiano Pochettino, his 31-year-old son. The overall package is just over $12million (£9m).
Finances were a consideration for United at the start of this process but circumstances became bleaker, following a 2-0 loss at Chelsea and a scrambled 4-4 home draw with Villa, as the team fell into the relegation places. United finding such money now will probably frustrate Carrick, who could have used it for signings in this year’s summer transfer window.
Pochettino would have cost United nothing in the immediate aftermath of the World Cup, when he was a free agent as his initial two-year contract with U.S. Soccer had expired following the last-16 loss to Belgium on July 6. On August 3, he signed a new deal running to 2030 and including that release clause.
United felt back then that targeting World Cup coaches, including Germany’s Julian Nagelsmann, was impractical and that Carrick deserved a chance after earning Champions League qualification last season following his January appointment as interim head coach.
But it does add up to another costly episode for the club, following on from swift, expensive reversals on Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim and sporting director Dan Ashworth. Overall, the cost of hiring and firing these key personnel since 2024 tops £40million.
Upon arriving at United as co-owner in early 2024, Ratcliffe said: “If you look at the 11 years that have gone since David Gill and Sir Alex stepped down, there have been a whole series of coaches — some of which were very good. And none of them was successful or survived for very long. And you can’t blame all the coaches. The only conclusion you can draw is that the environment in which they were working didn’t work.”
But the price of United’s next head coach could have been even higher.
According to sources, there was high-level contact from United to Brighton & Hove Albion, whose rise to second place in the Premier League has been one of the stories of the season, to ask about the chances of recruiting their head coach Fabian Hurzeler.
Brighton owner Tony Bloom told United the price of doing so would be £15million ($20m). Regardless, Hurzeler, a 33-year-old U.S.-born German, wants to complete this season with Brighton, which made the possibility of a move remote. Other sources have told The Athletic it may have taken an even higher figure than £15m to secure him.
And so, despite Pochettino looking like the chosen candidate, United held an executive committee (ExCo) meeting last Thursday, November 5, where he, Emery and Hurzeler featured in the conversation.
There was also a fourth name discussed: Cesc Fabregas.
The former Arsenal captain, now head coach at Italian club Como, oversaw a brilliant 4-1 Champions League win against United in October that triggered the endgame for Carrick. Berrada has rated the 39-year-old Spaniard since he led Como to Champions League qualification last season but talk on Fabregas did not develop to anything further.
Out of those four names, two could be considered proven, established managers, while two are exciting young coaches. United decided the profile they want and need is at the more experienced end.
United had prior to that point extended the net wider, during what they call a thorough review of the head coach position, starting after the 3-0 home loss to Bournemouth on October 25. They considered Carrick’s position the day after, and were internally calculating the projected costs of firing him and hiring another coach, but ultimately executives decided to give the 45-year-old former United midfielder three more games to turn results around — against Chelsea, Roma and Villa.
During that time, they also surveyed the market. Contact was made regarding Didier Deschamps, who stepped down as France manager after the World Cup to end a 14-year reign, but those conversations did not go well, leaving people at United feeling that he was looking to gain leverage for a move to work in Saudi Arabia. In September, French newspaper L’Equipe reported that Jeddah club Al Ahli’s executive director, Fabrice Bocquet, had offered Deschamps, 58, a three-year contract with a salary of around €10million (£8.3m; $11m) per season.
Other names came into play, not least Antonio Conte, the highest-profile manager currently out of work.
Ratcliffe showed interest in exploring the 57-year-old Italian as a candidate, given his credentials in winning the Premier League and Serie A six times with four different clubs, but others at United felt he would not be the right fit in the circumstances. Conte would have been interested in taking charge but is believed to desire authority and to feel a firm grip is needed to govern players who must take greater responsibility for results.
Representatives contacted United to make them aware of Conte’s availability, having left Napoli at the end of last season, but the club never followed up on it by holding any conversations.
Some people at the club felt Eddie Howe had a compelling case, following his work at Bournemouth and more recently Newcastle United. Sources say director of football Jason Wilcox looked into whether the 48-year-old Englishman, who stood down at Newcastle in late July, was suitable. But ultimately the matter did not progress further and he was left off the final names considered.
Christopher Vivell, United’s director of recruitment, likes 39-year-old Nagelsmann, a free agent after leaving the Germany job following their early World Cup exit. But hiring a manager new to the Premier League in United’s current plight would be risky. Sebastian Hoeness, 44, of German club Stuttgart, another with no experience of English football, also came up briefly.
But all roads ultimately led to Pochettino. Some sources feel that his hire was due to brothers Joel and Avram Glazer, whose American family remain the club’s majority owners, exerting more influence than they have previously since Ratcliffe arrived in February 2024. They say Pochettino was the primary choice of the Glazers.
Those who know the Glazers say it is not their style to deliver ultimatums, but they have been alert to goings-on at the club and would subtly reassert their views if they felt it necessary.
One link between the family and Pochettino is billionaire Ken Griffin, who donated to U.S. Soccer when they hired the former Tottenham Hotspur, Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea manager in September 2024. Griffin had helped the Glazers buy United in 2005, as founder of Citadel, which was one of three hedge funds used for the leveraged takeover supplying PIK (payment in kind) loans estimated to be worth around £220million. But sources stress nothing should be read into that and the key component to Pochettino’s appointment is the judgement made by the club’s football leadership once his exit clause at U.S. Soccer was known.
Sources say Ratcliffe was also fully on board with hiring him, and the unanimous decision taken at the ExCo meeting, involving all relevant directors held three days before the Villa game, was to go for the Argentinian in the event of moving on from Carrick. The club insist speculation about different preferences between leadership and ownership is categorically false and that Pochettino was the only candidate they spoke to directly.
Following further conversations at a summit for Ratcliffe’s INEOS business empire in Monaco last week, Berrada contacted U.S. Soccer on Wednesday evening to inform them of United’s intention to trigger Pochettino’s $10million release clause.
There are people at the club who anticipate he will assume greater authority once in the building than his job title of head coach would suggest, taking on more of an old-school manager role.
Pochettino is regarded as a reasonable person to work alongside, as his relationship with then Tottenham chairman Daniel Levy over five years would testify. But some who know him also predict he will want a significant say on player recruitment.
Pochettino’s return to English football will come once the second and final USMNT game of this international break, against Haiti in Cincinnati, Ohio, finishes in the early hours of Wednesday UK time. His first match with United pitches him straight into the fire away to arch-rivals Liverpool next Sunday, meaning he will have just three training sessions to get acquainted with the players he’s inheriting from Carrick.
This hiring is the culmination of a decade-long dalliance, which dates back to 2016, when he was in the running to replace Louis van Gaal, only for Avram Glazer to propose that United needed a manager with a track record of winning the biggest trophies, sealing Jose Mourinho’s appointment instead.
Pochettino then got down to the last two in 2022, when he was at PSG, but Ten Hag was selected after he presented a detailed tactical plan for every scenario. Sources involved in the process at the time suspected Pochettino felt his body of work spoke for itself and he wasn’t necessarily ready for the rigours of the actual interview process in the same way as Ten Hag. Pochettino’s approach leant towards building a culture and getting team togetherness, but United felt Ten Hag’s approach was more suited to the club at the time.
Joel Glazer was on the panel then, alongside football director John Murtough and chief executive Richard Arnold, in a manager search organised by Mike Forde, a sports recruiter based in New York. Darren Fletcher offered input into the process as technical director, and will now do so from his position as under-18s head coach, with Pochettino expected to tap into United’s academy.
Pochettino also interviewed in 2024, under the current regime, when Berrada and Wilcox were beginning at United. Both parties left that conversation feeling like they would not be working together. Instead, Thomas Tuchel and Roberto De Zerbi made the final two, before Ten Hag was kept on for another six months.
Pochettino was said to be burnt out after difficult periods at PSG and then Chelsea, and not the best version of himself. Although he has been rejuvenated in the States, his appointment two years after that episode is still a turnaround of sorts. On Friday, Pochettino credited his experience at U.S. Soccer with restoring his motivation during the press conference ahead of his penultimate game in charge — a 6-0 win, also against Haiti, on Saturday.
Lawyer Mariano Aguilar has been handling the talks on his behalf and informed United of the release clause in that new USMNT contract. Pochettino has famously negotiated his own terms in the past and seemingly he learnt from the deal he signed with Tottenham in 2018, which contained no such buyout language.
He made sure he had an exit plan this time, after leading the American side at a World Cup played largely on home soil, although in his tearful farewell he insisted that was also to protect the federation.
He said it was on Sunday afternoon that it “started to appear, this type of situation” with United — so in the immediate aftermath of the chaotic 4-4 draw with Villa at Old Trafford earlier that day.
Monday at U.S. Soccer’s National Training Center in Atlanta, Georgia, was deemed business as usual by many present. But that is when Pochettino’s representatives first contacted the body, saying that contact with United had occurred the previous night.
U.S. Soccer did have some initial hope that Pochettino could be persuaded to stay, such had been his level of engagement with long-term planning, the opportunity to work out of that newly-constructed training facility, and the prospect of building on the optimism generated by the World Cup.
He and his wife were also said to be enjoying the pace of life in the States, which afforded them a little more family time, having recently welcomed grandchildren. Pochettino’s deeply emotional press conference on Friday morning suggested that cutting the cord had weighed heavily on him, also underlined by his willingness to see through this two-leg Concacaf Nations League quarter-final against Haiti before heading to Manchester.
His representatives also made clear to United that the full clause would be required to release him from his U.S. role, ensuring the federation secured a vast return on that new contract signed only three months ago.
Deep down, however, even U.S. Soccer’s most senior personnel would have known that a call from Old Trafford was always likely to spell trouble.
Pochettino had been transparent with executives during his time in the States that there are a small number of elite clubs which remain a dream for him, and United was always among those. From Tuesday afternoon onwards, it was merely a case of resolving the financials and formalities, even if United’s direct approach to the federation only came the following day.
An agreement was struck on Thursday, Pochettino said, and that is when he told his USMNT players. “Very transparent,” he added. “They were very supportive.”
He did not wish to get into discussing his new club yet, though. “We have time next week to talk about the job at Manchester United,” he explained.
During Carrick’s two days on the edge this week, Tuesday and Wednesday, televisions at their training ground showed Sky Sports News somewhat awkwardly reporting on Pochettino’s looming arrival.
Undoubtedly, even more TV cameras will descend on United next week for the start of his reign in earnest.
At last.
Additional reporting: James Horncastle, Matt Slater




