New Delhi: India's decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out of the playing XI for the opening Test against New Zealand at Wellington's Basin Reserve has drawn criticism from several former cricketers and cricket commentators, including Sunil Gavaskar, Ravi Shastri, Wasim Jaffer and Harsha Bhogle.
The selection call is set to attract further scrutiny in view of New Zealand recovering from 70 for five to finish the opening day at 243 for five on Thursday (November 19). An unbeaten 173-run partnership between Henry Nicholls, who scored 113, and Glenn Phillips, who remained not out on 94, helped the hosts recover after India had made early inroads into their batting line-up.
India preferred Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna over Siraj. All-rounder Ravindra Jadeja was also left out, with Washington Sundar selected as the spin-bowling option.
The decision surprised several commentators, particularly given Siraj's experience in overseas conditions and his contribution to India's recent Test campaigns. According to Wisden, Siraj is India's leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship cycle, with 43 wickets at an average of 26.81.
Former cricketers question selection decision
Former India head coach Ravi Shastri questioned the logic behind Siraj's omission, particularly if pace, skill and seam movement were the criteria for selecting the bowling attack.
In a post on X, Shastri, who gave Siraj his Test debut in Australia, wrote: "Hope India bounce back strongly. But if pace, skill and seam movement were the criteria, and 140 clicks was hard to come by, one has to ask the question. Where was MOHD SIRAJ? Experience, aggression and the ability to make things happen with the ball. Surely that counts for something!"
Cricket commentator Harsha Bhogle also expressed disappointment over the decision. In a post on X on November 18, Bhogle said he was "flabbergasted and disappointed" that India had left Siraj out.
"He has done everything asked of him, lifted the attack in the absence of Bumrah, been a great, positive team player," Bhogle wrote, adding that he hoped the management would have "some very honest conversations with Siraj".
Former India opener Wasim Jaffer also criticised the decision, highlighting Siraj's contribution to India's Test campaign in England and his standing in the current WTC cycle.
Jaffer wrote on X: "I can still understand the case for Washington Sundar over Jadeja, given New Zealand's left handers. But Siraj being left out is absolutely shocking."
He added that Siraj, whom he credited with playing a decisive role in levelling the England series, had been left out despite conditions that could have suited his bowling.
"India are already missing him on Day 1. This is Siraj territory, building partnerships, tiring batters and making things happen with his relentless work ethic," Jaffer wrote.
Former India captain Sunil Gavaskar also questioned the omission during a broadcast on Sony Sports Network. He said he did not believe Siraj had let the team down and pointed out that there was nothing wrong with the pacer's bowling or rhythm.
Gavaskar also questioned the decision to prefer relatively inexperienced Test bowlers over Siraj, reportedly saying that considering the latter was not among India's four leading bowlers was "a little hard to get over".
Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin also reacted to the selection. In a post on X, he wrote, "Harsh, very Harsh but this is the new normal." He subsequently clarified that the phrase was intended as a sarcastic expression of acceptance of such selection decisions.
Former India batter Aakash Chopra also expressed surprise at the absence of both Siraj and Jadeja from the playing XI.
Gill and team management defend combination
India captain Shubman Gill acknowledged at the toss that leaving Siraj and Gurnoor Brar out had been a difficult decision. He said the team management had spent the preceding week considering different combinations because of the performances of its fast bowlers.
"We were contemplating for the past week which combination to go with because all of our fast bowlers have been doing really well. Very difficult for Siraj and Gurnoor, both of them, to miss out," Gill said.
India's batting coach Sitanshu Kotak later defended the selection, saying that the playing XI had been chosen with the requirements of the entire five-day match in mind rather than the conditions on the opening day alone.
“… There is nothing wrong [with Siraj].” he said after day one of the Test with New Zealand. “Like I said that's the best possible XI the team management thought [there] was and that is the one which played.”
“…This is just the first day … So when you pick an XI, you think about all four or five days [that] it will go on [for], it's not just one day. So I think that's the best possible bowling attack we felt and that's the one which played," Kotak told reporters.
He also explained that Sundar's selection over Jadeja was influenced by the presence of four left-handed batters in New Zealand's top order.
Meanwhile, the opening day's proceedings have added to the discussion surrounding India's bowling combination. Bumrah took three wickets, while Kamboj and Deep claimed one each. Krishna and Sundar went wicketless as Nicholls and Phillips stabilised the innings.

