US President Donald Trump’s public request for Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto to stand during a summit in Manila has prompted criticism from Indonesian social media users and an international relations scholar, who questioned whether the exchange reflected the principle of mutual respect between sovereign leaders.
The moment occurred on November 17 during the US-ASEAN Special Summit, as Trump discussed expanding defence cooperation between Washington and Jakarta. He paused his remarks to look for the Indonesian president among the leaders attending the meeting.
“Where is Indonesia? I saw my friend here someplace. Would you please stand up? He’s such a shy person,” Trump said, prompting Prabowo to rise from his seat.
Trump then praised his Indonesian counterpart, saying he was “doing a great job” and congratulating him as a “great leader”.
Although the remarks were complimentary overall, the request to stand and the personal description of Prabowo prompted questions about the tone and symbolism of the interaction. The episode has renewed attention to how informal gestures between heads of state can be interpreted in public diplomatic settings.
Diplomatic gestures and presidential dignity
Diplomatic communication extends beyond speeches, formal agreements and official statements. Gestures, posture and the way leaders address one another in public can also carry political and symbolic significance.
A head of state represents not only an individual but also the authority and sovereignty of the country they lead. As a result, seemingly casual exchanges between leaders can take on wider meaning when they occur before an international audience.
Trump’s request placed Prabowo in the position of being publicly singled out and asked to stand. His description of the Indonesian president as “shy” added a personal element that some observers interpreted as condescending.
The exchange also reflected Trump’s tendency to project dominance and superiority through forceful, personal interactions, while Prabowo did not appear particularly equipped to respond to that kind of public provocation.
That interpretation, however, does not establish that Trump intended to insult Prabowo or Indonesia.
But the episode, nevertheless, illustrates how differences in communication styles and political personalities can create diplomatic sensitivities, particularly when leaders represent countries with unequal economic and military influence.
Indonesian social media users question Trump’s gesture
The exchange attracted reactions from Indonesian social media users after a video of the summit was shared by Tribun Sumsel. Some commenters questioned whether Trump’s remarks were genuinely complimentary or carried a more demeaning undertone.
One commenter, using the account @superhero6397, argued that the interaction should not be interpreted as praise.
“This isn’t praise, but rather humiliation. Prabowo was ordered to stand like a superior addressing his subordinate,” the commenter wrote.
Another user, @nyomansunada1000, expressed concern that the exchange could be interpreted in different ways depending on how Trump’s words and gestures were understood.
“I’m worried it’s misunderstood… either as a compliment or as an insult/demeaning (in a subtle way),” the user commented.
The reactions illustrate how an interaction between world leaders can resonate domestically, particularly when questions of national dignity and equality between sovereign states are involved. However, social media comments should not be taken as representative of Indonesian public opinion as a whole.
Scholar questions Trump’s diplomatic conduct
Dr. Teuku Rezasyah, an international relations scholar at President University, offered a critical assessment of Trump’s conduct in comments to Indonesia Business Post (IBP). He argued that the US president’s approach appeared inconsistent with Indonesia’s cultural emphasis on courtesy and diplomatic respect.
“Trump comes across as arrogant and appears not to understand Indonesia’s culture, which places great importance on politeness and courtesy,” Rezasyah said.
He also argued that the exchange did not reflect the principle of mutual respect expected in diplomatic relations.
“Under diplomatic protocol, countries should uphold mutual respect,” he said.
Rezasyah further suggested that Trump would be unlikely to address Russian President Vladimir Putin or Chinese President Xi Jinping in the same manner, raising questions about whether leaders from countries with different levels of global influence receive different treatment.
Nevertheless, he identified a potentially positive interpretation of the exchange, despite what he considered an inappropriate manner of interaction.
“One positive takeaway, although the exchange appeared somewhat inappropriate, is that it shows President Trump and President Prabowo already know each other well,” he said.
His assessment points to a tension in personal diplomacy: familiarity between political leaders can help build closer relations, but it does not remove the importance of protocol and respect for the offices they hold.
Prabowo does not challenge the request
Prabowo stood when Trump called on him and turned towards the US president as he continued speaking. He did not publicly challenge the request, and the exchange proceeded without an open disagreement between the two leaders.
The interaction took place against the backdrop of efforts by Washington and Jakarta to deepen their defence relationship. During the same remarks, Trump referred to a partnership intended to expand joint special forces training and support Indonesia’s defence modernisation.
That context gives the exchange significance beyond the personalities of the two presidents. Indonesia is seeking to strengthen cooperation with the United States while maintaining its independent position in relations with major international powers.
For Jakarta, the distinction is important: close strategic ties do not remove the expectation that both countries treat each other as sovereign equals.
Ultimately, the exchange shows how the language and gestures of political leaders can shape perceptions of a bilateral relationship, even when the stated intention is friendly. Trump’s praise of Prabowo was clear; whether the manner in which he delivered it reflected the mutual respect expected between heads of state remains open to interpretation.




