What began as a crude attempt to change the condition of a ball has developed into a soap opera that keeps giving

Daryll Cullinan

Published: Nov 19, 2026, 1:07 PM (4 hrs ago)

There have been some extraordinary Test matches in cricket's history, but nothing quite like Sandpapergate. Eight years after the first ball was bowled, the contest is still going, the players are arguing over what happened, and the administrators appear increasingly desperate to call it a draw.

What began as a rather crude attempt to change the condition of a cricket ball has developed into one of the great sporting soap operas. Three players were punished, an entire nation was traumatised, politicians expressed their outrage, and cricket was supposedly brought to its knees.

The hysteria was extraordinary, and eight years later the sequel is only warming up.

Related

Cummins goes above and beyond, but questions remain

Warner claims 2018 ball-tampering investigation 'stinks of a cover-up'

Never mind Sandpapergate, cricket needs to set clear boundaries for ball management

The key takeaways from Cameron Bancroft's revelations about sandpapergate

Why is Australia so outraged at Steven Smith's team? (2018)

For some reason, cricket has always struggled to come to terms with the discovery that cricketers occasionally cheat. This is particularly amusing in a game where players spend hours working on the condition of the ball, occasionally forgetting which methods are permitted and which might constitute an assault on a nation's values.

Few sports enjoy such a peculiar relationship with their own equipment. Cricket has seen fingernails, mints, Vaseline, bottle tops, trouser zips, and an assortment of other objects used in the pursuit of extracting a little extra movement. Some practices are celebrated as skill, others dismissed as gamesmanship, and a few treated as crimes against humanity.

The Australians cheated, were caught red-handed, and deserved punishment. But was the punishment proportionate? If cheating is cheating, why should sandpaper attract such extraordinary outrage when other forms of illegal ball-tampering have been treated far more leniently? Is the guilty party in all of this not the governance if it all by the game's lawmakers?

The old proverb "When thieves fall out, honest men come by their own" seems particularly appropriate now that the once united Australian dressing room has begun producing competing versions of events, but I fear that honest men may never appear.

Usman Khawaja and David Warner, safely retired, have discovered a renewed enthusiasm for speaking out. Retirement, it seems, does wonders for a cricketer's conscience. Memories sharpen, courage grows, and matters that once seemed best left unsaid suddenly become important.

Khawaja's timing is particularly interesting, with his account emerging alongside an autobiography. His recollections may be entirely sincere, but there is something wonderfully convenient about discovering the importance of speaking out when doing so can no longer threaten your place in the side. I have never found much courage in criticising former team-mates from the safety of retirement.

For some reason, cricket has always struggled with the notion that cricketers occasionally cheat. And this is a game where players spend hours working on the condition of the ball, occasionally forgetting which methods are permitted and which might constitute an assault on a nation's values

Cameron Bancroft, meanwhile, has acknowledged withholding important information during the original investigation. He deserves some credit for admitting it, although it presents an obvious difficulty. Having told us his original account was incomplete, he must now convince us that the latest version is entirely reliable. Eight years is a long time to remember precisely which parts of the truth were previously considered unnecessary.

Steve Smith offers his own contribution to this comedy of errors. As captain, he admitted becoming aware of the proposed wrongdoing and choosing to walk away. An unusual interpretation of leadership, although perhaps he was demonstrating his confidence in the team's ability to make independent decisions!

And then there is Pat Cummins.

I have enormous respect for Cummins as a cricketer and captain, which makes his present predicament all the more unfortunate. He maintains that he knew nothing about the sandpaper, a position he is perfectly entitled to defend.

But there is something almost comical about the contest that exists now between various people's versions of what happened. Cummins might have enjoyed better luck persuading the public that pigs can fly.

Of course, disbelief is not proof, and the distinction matters. But by dismissing the competing accounts so emphatically, Cummins has left himself precious little room to manoeuvre. An absolute denial is a difficult position to retreat from, particularly when every new revelation presents another delivery to negotiate. Sadly this will follow him for the rest of his life.

For Cummins and for that matter, every member of the touring party in 2018, you can retire from a cricket career, but not from your own conscience, and that is the greatest sentence of all.

Yet perhaps the greatest irony, and certainly the greatest responsibility, belongs to Cricket Australia.

In 2018, it investigated the matter, punished three players and considered the business settled. Now, faced with conflicting accounts, it has proposed an independent discussion forum where everyone can share their memories, without reopening the investigation or contemplating further punishment.

A splendid administrative solution! Invite everyone into a room, encourage them to get things off their chests, assure them there will be no consequences, and hope they emerge sufficiently relieved to stop talking about it.

The three who served their bans might reasonably wonder why such generosity was unavailable eight years ago, and herein lies the serious point beneath all the amusement.

If responsibility extended beyond the three punished players, as the latest allegations suggest, Cricket Australia's investigation begins to look less like a search for the truth and more like an exercise in finding a plausible resolution. Someone has to take the hit fair and square, to bring closure, and for me, this needs to be Cricket Australia, because they can't reasonably expect everyone else to revisit their conduct while their own handling of the affair escapes equally close examination.

For decades Australian cricketers have celebrated Test victories by singing "Under the Southern Cross I Stand". By all accounts a wonderful tradition, celebrating national pride, loyalty and a bond between men who have stood together through thick and thin.

Although, judging by Sandpapergate, that bond appears considerably stronger when celebrating victory than when sharing responsibility. Eight years later the same men who once sang in harmony can barely agree on what happened in their own dressing room.

They say the truth will set you free, and Mark Twain is often credited with having observed that if you tell the truth, you don't have to remember anything. Unfortunately neither piece of wisdom appears to have caught on in Australian cricket. In Bancroft's defence we may have seen the closest version of it.

So, eight years on I suspect the whole truth has about as much chance of emerging as those flying pigs. Instead we are left to weigh probabilities against improbabilities, with everyone free to decide which version they find more believable. And so, the longest-running Test match in history continues. It's not the ball being tampered with now but the truth.

Daryll Cullinan played 70 Tests for South Africa between 1993 and 2001